Surviving Isn’t Thriving: Why Early Childhood Must Stop Running on Empty

The quiet normal

Ask an early childhood leader how their week is going and you will often hear the same answer: “We got through it.”

Rosters rebuilt at 6.30am. Programming finished at the kitchen table. Breaks taken standing up, if at all. A director covering the floor while the inbox fills. None of it is dramatic, and that is exactly the problem. Survival mode has become so familiar that many of us no longer notice it.

There are seasons when survival is the right response: an illness outbreak, a sudden resignation, the week of an assessment visit. The danger comes when a season becomes a system, and “just coping” is quietly accepted as the standard for a profession entrusted with children at the most formative stage of their lives.

Survival mode is not a personal failing of tired educators, and it is not an unavoidable feature of our sector. It is a matter of leadership, governance and culture. The research, our regulatory framework and our sense of calling all point the same way: children need educators who are thriving, and thriving educators need services designed to sustain them.

What the research is telling us

The strongest predictor of an educator planning to leave is emotional exhaustion. It is not age, role or service type.

In a national study of 713 Australian early childhood professionals, Macquarie University researchers found that about one in three intended to leave the profession. Emotional exhaustion predicted that intention for directors and educators alike. Among educators, lower satisfaction with pay and benefits also mattered (Bull et al., 2024).

What participants said in their own words is just as telling. Their reasons for leaving clustered around three themes:

  • Feeling undervalued: the low status of the sector and limited career progression.
  • Rising demands without matching support: administrative and regulatory load, complex child and family needs, and work spilling into personal time.
  • Workforce pressures: pay disparities and the difficulty of finding quality permanent and relief staff.

These findings are consistent with a systematic review of 39 international studies, including Australian ones, led by Dr Marg Rogers at the University of New England. The review linked burnout to service cultures with little focus on wellbeing, scarce emotional support and poor respect for work–life balance. It also pointed to high expectations of quality paired with few resources, and the burden of excessive data collection to prove quality (The Conversation, 2023).

The sector’s own voice is louder still. A 2021 United Workers Union survey of around 4,000 educators reported that 73 per cent planned to leave within three years, and 82 per cent often or always felt rushed in key caring tasks. As an advocacy survey, it should be read as a strong signal rather than a precise measure. Even so, the signal is hard to ignore.

One caution matters here. Most of this research is cross-sectional: it shows strong associations, not proof of cause. But when national surveys, peer-reviewed studies and lived experience all point in the same direction, leaders should take notice.

Why this is about children, not only staff

Educator wellbeing is a children’s issue, because relationships are the core of quality and depleted adults struggle to offer them.

The Early Years Learning Framework (V2.0) places secure, respectful and reciprocal relationships at the centre of children’s learning. Quality Area 5 of the National Quality Standard asks for responsive, meaningful interactions that help each child feel secure, confident and included. That kind of attunement needs emotional energy, patience and presence. Those are exactly the resources that survival mode drains first.

International research supports this link. In a review of the evidence, Roberts and colleagues (2019) summarise studies showing that early childhood teachers with more depressive symptoms tend to have less sensitive, more withdrawn interactions with children. Their classrooms tend to show lower quality, and their children make fewer social-emotional gains (Roberts et al., 2019). One US study found that teacher depression predicted a lower-quality care climate, which in turn predicted more behavioural difficulties in children (Jeon, Buettner & Snyder, 2014).

Jennings and Greenberg’s “prosocial classroom” model offers a helpful way to hold this together. Educators’ own wellbeing and social-emotional capacity shape the relationships and climate they create, and that climate shapes children’s outcomes. It is a model, not a proof, and most of these studies come from the United States. But the direction is clear enough for leaders to act on.

Turnover compounds the harm. Every time a familiar educator leaves, a child loses a secure attachment figure and a family loses a trusted relationship. Australian researchers have noted that this instability weakens the quality of relationships and interactions, and undermines long-term efforts to build a quality workforce (Thorpe et al., 2020).

The numbers are improving, so why does it still feel like survival?

On paper, the workforce picture is better than it has been for years. That is good news, and it tells us something important: survival mode is not only a staffing-supply problem.

As at 1 April 2026, 5.1 per cent of services held a staffing waiver, down from 9.1 per cent two years earlier (ACECQA, 2026). Almost 90 per cent of waivers relate to meeting early childhood teacher requirements (ACECQA NQF Annual Performance Report 2025). The Australian Government’s funded 15 per cent wage increase has also helped retention.

Yet many leaders will recognise that their teams do not feel 15 per cent less tired. Three things help explain the gap:

  • The work has become more complex. Educators describe more children with additional needs, more families under pressure and more documentation, often without matching inclusion or allied health support.
  • Expectations keep rising, rightly. The child safety reforms that began on 1 September 2025 brought new requirements for digital technology policies, 24-hour notification of alleged physical and sexual abuse, refinements to Quality Areas 2 and 7 from 1 January 2026, and mandatory child protection training (ACECQA, 2025). These changes matter deeply for children. But reforms land on teams, and when implementation is not resourced, the load falls on whoever is already carrying the most.
  • Being compliant on ratios is not the same as having sustainable work. A service can meet Regulation 123 every hour of the day and still have no non-contact time, no relief cover and no one with the capacity to mentor a new graduate.

A SafeWork NSW review published in March 2026 noted that workers may not report psychosocial harm because they see such incidents as a natural part of the job (SafeWork NSW, 2026). That phrase captures exactly what normalising survival mode looks like.

Called to flourish, not just survive

For Christian services, there is a particular temptation to name. We can spiritualise exhaustion. Calling and sacrifice are real parts of our story, so it is easy to treat overwork as faithfulness and to praise the educator who never stops.

Scripture offers a different picture.

Rest is built into the design. From the creation narrative to the Sabbath commandment, rest is not a reward for finishing the work. It is part of the rhythm God gives. Jesus reminded his listeners that the Sabbath was made for people, not people for the Sabbath. In Mark 6, after a season of intense ministry, he invited his disciples to come away to a quiet place and rest a while.

Unsustainable work is a structural problem. In Exodus 18, Moses is judging the people from morning until evening. His father-in-law Jethro does not tell him to pray harder or try a resilience course. He tells him plainly that what he is doing is not good, that he will wear himself out, and that the work is too heavy for one person. The answer is to redesign the system: share the load, build capable leaders and organise the work differently. That is a leadership lesson for every approved provider.

People are image-bearers, not resources. Every educator carries God-given dignity. Stewarding a team well means caring for the whole person, not extracting as much as possible from them until they leave.

Flourishing is the goal. In John 10:10, Jesus speaks of coming so that people may have life to the full. That vision applies to the children in our care. It also applies to the adults who care for them. A service that forms children in love, joy and hope cannot be sustained by adults who are running on empty.

None of this means removing challenge or effort from the work. Meaningful work is demanding. But there is a difference between a demanding calling and a depleting system, and Christian leaders should be among the first to recognise it.

From surviving to thriving: where leaders can start

The research points to the same lesson as Jethro: change the system, not just the person. Resilience workshops and morning teas have their place, but they cannot offset a workload that is structurally unsustainable.

Here are eight practical starting points, drawn from the evidence above.

  1. Protect non-contact time. Treat programming, planning and educational leadership time as rostered, not optional, and track how often it is lost to the floor.
  2. Cut what does not serve children. Audit documentation for duplication. Ask of every form and record: who reads this, and what difference does it make? Researchers have found that excessive data collection to prove quality is itself a driver of burnout.
  3. Support the supporters. Directors and educational leaders carry heavy emotional and regulatory loads. Build in coaching, peer mentoring or professional supervision for them, not only for new graduates.
  4. Respect the boundaries of work. Notice and reduce unpaid hours, after-hours messages and missed breaks. Make flexible leave for family responsibilities genuinely available.
  5. Resource every reform. When new requirements arrive, such as the 2025–26 child safety changes, plan the time, training and backfill needed to implement them well, rather than adding them on top.
  6. Treat wellbeing as a quality and WHS issue. Include workload and psychosocial risks in your risk register and your Quality Improvement Plan. Consult your team about the hazards they experience, as WHS law expects.
  7. Govern it. Boards and approved providers should regularly see indicators such as turnover, sick leave, vacancies, overtime and exit interview themes. What gets governed gets attention.
  8. Lean into your peak body. No leader should have to work this out alone. Peak bodies such as Christian Early Learning (CEL) exist to walk alongside services: offering trusted advice on regulatory change, professional learning, leadership coaching and a network of leaders who understand both the pressures of the sector and the calling behind the work. Reaching out early, before a season of survival becomes a system, is a sign of good stewardship, not weakness.

Questions for your next team or leadership meeting

  • If our current pace continued for another year, what would it cost our children, our team and our families?
  • Which tasks do we do because they help children, and which do we do because we always have?
  • Where in our week do educators get time to think, plan and reflect, and is that time protected?
  • How would we know if someone on our team was quietly running on empty?
  • What is one structural change, not a personal tip, we could make this term?

Time to stop calling it normal

Getting through the day should never be the highest ambition we hold for the people who shape children’s earliest years.

The evidence is clear that exhaustion drives people out of the profession. It is reasonably consistent that depleted adults find it harder to offer the warm, responsive relationships children need. The National Quality Framework exists first and foremost for the safety, health and wellbeing of children, and rested, supported educators are better placed to uphold it. And our faith tells us that rest, shared load and flourishing are part of God’s design for work, not a luxury we get to once the roster is covered.

Survival mode will sometimes be necessary. It should never be the plan. Surviving isn’t thriving, and our children, our educators and our communities deserve services that are doing more than running on empty.

References

  • ACECQA (2025). NQF Annual Performance Report 2025: Summary. Link
  • ACECQA (2025). Summary of Child Safety Review changes 2025–2026. Link
  • ACECQA (2026). Proportion of education and care services with staffing waivers continues to fall. Link
  • Bull, R., McFarland, L., Cumming, T., & Wong, S. (2024). The impact of work-related wellbeing and workplace culture and climate on intention to leave in the early childhood sector. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 69, 13–24. Link
  • Jeon, L., Buettner, C. K., & Snyder, A. R. (2014). Pathways from teacher depression and child-care quality to child behavioral problems. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. Summary: ScienceDaily
  • Roberts, A. M., Gallagher, K. C., Daro, A. M., Iruka, I. U., & Sarver, S. L. (2019). Workforce well-being: Personal and workplace contributions to early educators’ depression across settings. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 61, 4–12. Link
  • Rogers, M. (2023). Early educators around the world feel burnt out and devalued. Here’s how we can help. The Conversation. Link
  • SafeWork NSW (2026). Work health and safety hazards in the early childhood education and care sector: Summary. Link
  • Thorpe, K., et al. (2020). Identifying predictors of retention and professional wellbeing of the early childhood education workforce in a time of change. Journal of Educational Change, 21, 623–647. Link
  • Education and Care Services National Law; Education and Care Services National Regulations; National Quality Standard; Belonging, Being and Becoming: The Early Years Learning Framework for Australia (V2.0, 2022).

Christian Early Learning 2026